jfrost2 wrote:...The 125 is more powerful than the 150 anyways, at take off at least...
...most people assume the 150 is faster just because it's bigger, so it likely come down to being a selling point.
This is from upthread a ways - I'm just wondering, why is the 125 faster than than the 150 at take off?
Yeah, me too! Why's the 125 faster on take-off? This might actually make a difference in what scooter I buy when I actually get around to buying. Hubby just bought a red 125 and I like it a lot, it's off the line plenty fast enough for me. I don't care too much about top end...I just like the 150's because of the colors.
I don't like banning people and we don't do it often here. For what it's worth, I was (mostly) joking in my original thread "calling him out." But he decided to be a dick about it and when I told him to mind his manners, he became a bigger dick about it.
Anyone who spends any time here should know I have no problem with anyone disagreeing with me or offering information that conflicts with mine. But whatever the case, members have to be respectful—not just to me, but to everyone else. ModernBuddy strives to maintain a higher standard of behavior than elsewhere online. That's one of the most important objectives here.
Eric // LA Scooter Meetup Group // Stella 4T // Vespa LX // Vespa LXS // Honda Helix // some, uh, projects…
InTheKnow... personally I thought he/she/it was an arrogant SOB from the get go. And frankly, to me, anyone who names themselves "InTheKnow" really oughta tone it down some and be a little more, or a lot more, humble to start with. Even if they actually did know absolutely everything
Peace and love...
Last edited by Skootz Kabootz on Tue May 26, 2009 2:18 am, edited 1 time in total.
Kaos wrote:
...most people assume the 150 is faster just because it's bigger, so it likely come down to being a selling point.
This is from upthread a ways - I'm just wondering, why is the 125 faster than than the 150 at take off?
Stock vs stock, with the same break in, it's not. Kaos's was faster because he broke his in a very specific way (and didn't leave it stock for too long).
And in reading reviews and talking to folks who have been on both scoots, even on the occasion the 125 is faster off the line, the ride on acceleration for the 150 is superior, and so is the top end (by a short bit). Again though, that's from what I've read, not personal experience.
Kaos wrote:
...most people assume the 150 is faster just because it's bigger, so it likely come down to being a selling point.
This is from upthread a ways - I'm just wondering, why is the 125 faster than than the 150 at take off?
Stock vs stock, with the same break in, it's not. Kaos's was faster because he broke his in a very specific way (and didn't leave it stock for too long).
The 125 has a longer stroke crank which generates more torque. That's why it has faster take off than the 150. Both bikes are so similar though in the end.
Last edited by jfrost2 on Mon Aug 03, 2009 6:48 pm, edited 1 time in total.
fretman wrote:
This is from upthread a ways - I'm just wondering, why is the 125 faster than than the 150 at take off?
Stock vs stock, with the same break in, it's not. Kaos's was faster because he broke his in a very specific way (and didn't leave it stock for too long).
The 125 has a longer camshaft arm which generates more torque. That's why it has faster take off than the 150. Both bikes are so similar though in the end.
Hate to correct you, but its got a longer stroke crank which provides more low end torque than the shorter throw 150's. So yes it *IS* faster off the line than a 150(even stock) but the 150 has more mid-range acceleration due to it having a bigger displacement.
If Genuine's rumored 270cc scooter will have a classic appearance, will it look like a Vespa or something else? Think of the possibilities (just, please, not like a Maico Mobil!).
Lostmycage wrote:
Stock vs stock, with the same break in, it's not. Kaos's was faster because he broke his in a very specific way (and didn't leave it stock for too long).
The 125 has a longer camshaft arm which generates more torque. That's why it has faster take off than the 150. Both bikes are so similar though in the end.
Hate to correct you, but its got a longer stroke crank which provides more low end torque than the shorter throw 150's. So yes it *IS* faster off the line than a 150(even stock) but the 150 has more mid-range acceleration due to it having a bigger displacement.
You know what's funny though, before I hit "Submit post" I sat there catching myself "was it camshaft....or stroke crank?" back and forth, back and forth, I even tried googling and searching in the forums, but I couldnt find it, so I just took a shot. It's been a while since anyone's brought it up, so I didnt remember off the top of my head anymore.
I edited to correct my original post. Thanks for the reminder Kaos.
jfrost2 wrote:
The 125 has a longer camshaft arm which generates more torque. That's why it has faster take off than the 150. Both bikes are so similar though in the end.
Hate to correct you, but its got a longer stroke crank which provides more low end torque than the shorter throw 150's. So yes it *IS* faster off the line than a 150(even stock) but the 150 has more mid-range acceleration due to it having a bigger displacement.
You know what's funny though, before I hit "Submit post" I sat there catching myself "was it camshaft....or stroke crank?" back and forth, back and forth, I even tried googling and searching in the forums, but I couldnt find it, so I just took a shot. It's been a while since anyone's brought it up, so I didnt remember off the top of my head anymore.
I edited to correct my original post. Thanks for the reminder Kaos.
The visual for the number of quotes on this is making me dizzy!
.::I know the voices in my head aren't real, but man do they come up with some great ideas::.
Not sure how I got here, was reading up on various scoots via search function: there is an insane wealth of info in these forums! Love it! Got a chuckle out of this thread. Exacty three years ago, "NO Blur, but a 270cc... and droppin' the 125s"
Heh. Figured some of you original posters might chuckle too! (...or sigh if you wanted the 300, if that's the case I apologize for the painful memory )
I was one of those who eagerly awaited the arrival of the Genuine Classic Cruiser...now in the same category as the Messiah, Godot and the Great Pumpkin. Looks like I'll be hanging on to my GTS 250, at least until Vespa comes out with a GTS 350.
PeterC wrote: at least until Vespa comes out with a GTS 305.
Fixed that for ya
Considering your 250 is pretty damn close to 250cc's and a GTS 300 is only 30 cc's more - one that Piaggio would brand a "350" would probably be more of a 305...
I'm almost surprised that Buddy didn't follow Kymco and others and called their 170i a "200"
PeterC wrote:I was one of those who eagerly awaited the arrival of the Genuine Classic Cruiser...now in the same category as the Messiah, Godot and the Great Pumpkin. Looks like I'll be hanging on to my GTS 250, at least until Vespa comes out with a GTS 350.
I'm still one of the hopeful. I'm so hopeful that I won't buy another HD200, or even a BV350. If I get to bored with the Fiddle I'll sell it and look for an old Riva 200 (not because of Larry Crowne, because they are available for pretty low bucks) and ride that for a while in hopes the Genuine Cruiser gets moved back to the front burner.
Maybe the few faithful could start a petition campaign for the Cruiser. If/when I get one, I'm naming it "Vapor".
PeterC wrote:I was one of those who eagerly awaited the arrival of the Genuine Classic Cruiser...now in the same category as the Messiah, Godot and the Great Pumpkin. Looks like I'll be hanging on to my GTS 250, at least until Vespa comes out with a GTS 350.
I'm still one of the hopeful. I'm so hopeful that I won't buy another HD200, or even a BV350. If I get to bored with the Fiddle I'll sell it and look for an old Riva 200 (not because of Larry Crowne, because they are available for pretty low bucks) and ride that for a while in hopes the Genuine Cruiser gets moved back to the front burner.
Maybe the few faithful could start a petition campaign for the Cruiser. If/when I get one, I'm naming it "Vapor".
Even though I couldn't hold out and got a GTS250, I'd sign that petition in a heartbeat. I loves me some consumer choice.
me too! seems like a lot of people are active for a year or two, then disappear. Maybe they just hit a level of enlightenment and scoot out to show the world .
I too would like to see a Genuine product that is bigger. I do love a good Vespa, but I can't justify $7k for a 300gts or whatnot. Kymco makes a few, and they are well loved, but they just don't excite me.
If you listen to the podcast on JustGottaScoot.com regarding Kemmy and his travels, they talk quite a bit about why they aren't trying anything new in the short term. Basically it came down to 'in order to stay afloat we need our tried and true products', and that is not unreasonable. Perhaps if there are a couple good years then they can go back to getting a cruiser rolling.
I too would like to see a 300cc cruiser from Genuine. But the tricky part is styling. You can either hit a home run or crash and burn when it comes to styling.
Most scoots have the way too modern cheesy sleek look. I have occasionally seen moderns that are executed pretty well overseas, but it's very rare. So it would have to be retro or modernized retro (my fav).
If Genuine had deep pockets, it would be great to let the Italians design something for them. It would be interesting to see what they'd come up with. But that will never happen.
The scooter was designed. Pretty much done from what I heard. And the influences were reportedly very European, classic touring style, like a Maicoletta or Heinkel, with nods to various German and French scoots and the Japanese Fujis.
NOT a sport maxi.
The scooter market has changed dramatically since the original post here. Don't really know the status of the cruiser or any other possible models. It's probably smart for now to focus on the core products and building and strengthening the dealer network before pushing new models. It's expensive to develop and import them, of course, but also hard for dealers to take on new ones.
Eric // LA Scooter Meetup Group // Stella 4T // Vespa LX // Vespa LXS // Honda Helix // some, uh, projects…
While waiting for Genuine to announce its Classic Cruiser, I’ve been trying to come up with the specs for my Ideal Scooter. I think I’ve come up with some of the criteria, but aesthetically, they are definitely influenced by my love of some of the long-departed classics, such as the Maicoletta, Heinkel Tourist and Zündapp Bella. Here are some suggestions:
1. At least 300-350cc engine, air-cooled horizontal opposed twin to keep center of gravity as low as possible.
2. At least 13” wheels.
3. Seat height no more than 30”.
4. Weight no more than 350 lbs. Could keep weight down with plastic body, alloy tube frame, aluminum engine block.
5. Disc brakes, front and rear.
6. Easy access to engine, drive train and wheels.
7. Complete instrumentation: speedometer, odometer, trip odometer, tachometer, clock, fuel gauge, engine temperature, ambient temperature.
8. Capacious glovebox.
9. Front and rear tires same size.
10. Spare tire.
11. Tires replaceable without removing other components.
12. LOUD horn (Stebel Nautilus?).
13. At least one 12Volt outlet.
14. Secure sidestand, a la Harley-Davidson.
15. 3-4-gallon gas tank.
16. Kick start, in addition to electric.
Personally, I don’t care if it’s 2T or 4T. I’d prefer a manual shift, but I’d settle for an automatic, a real automatic, not CVT…with a driveshaft, not a chain or belt.
ericalm wrote:The scooter was designed. Pretty much done from what I heard. And the influences were reportedly very European, classic touring style, like a Maicoletta or Heinkel, with nods to various German and French scoots and the Japanese Fujis.
NOT a sport maxi.
That sounds good as long as they toned it down somewhat. Some of the designs you mentioned are far too bulbous for general appeal and consumption. You and I think they're cool, but the unwashed masses may not think so. It needs a little bit of sleekness to it. But from what you described, it sounds up my alley. I guess I'll have to wait 10 years until it happens.
ericalm wrote:The scooter was designed. Pretty much done from what I heard. And the influences were reportedly very European, classic touring style, like a Maicoletta or Heinkel, with nods to various German and French scoots and the Japanese Fujis.
NOT a sport maxi.
That sounds good as long as they toned it down somewhat. Some of the designs you mentioned are far too bulbous for general appeal and consumption. You and I think they're cool, but the unwashed masses may not think so. It needs a little bit of sleekness to it. But from what you described, it sounds up my alley. I guess I'll have to wait 10 years until it happens.
Bulbous isn't so bad as long as it's fast. Fast and Bulbous. That's right!