Page 1 of 1

Brief handling comparison - my PX150 vs Stella 4T

Posted: Thu Apr 07, 2011 6:15 am
by desmolicious
I picked up my PX150 tonight from a shop in North Hills, LA where it had some carb work done.
I rode it back to Venice Beach down Sepulveda Blvd, a city road that then climbs and winds through some hills before a descent into the LA basin.

What was noticeable was that the PX felt more stable and hunkered down than my Stella 4T. The PX has a true 1 piece frame, while the Stella 4T is in 2 pieces.
But I'm thinking it's the tyres that are at play here. The Stella has the Sava white walls, while the PX has Michelin S83s. I'm looking forward to putting new meats on the Stella and seeing what happens.
Pressures are the same in both - 17/30.

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2011 12:55 am
by desmolicious
Due to the general consensus about how miserable Savas are, S83s will be fitted this Sat.
Then the Stella will be on even footing as the PX, so to speak, which will make handling comparisons far more relevant.

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2011 4:11 am
by ericalm
It'll be interesting to see what you think. What year is your PX?

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2011 6:12 am
by desmolicious
ericalm wrote:It'll be interesting to see what you think. What year is your PX?
2005. It has only 1700 miles on it and looks like new.
So I think it will be a pretty fair comparison to my Stella 4T once that has the same tyres put on.

Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 12:20 am
by desmolicious
Got the S83s put on! Felt a bit better but it was very windy today which was blowing everything around. Including the bike. So I'll need to wait for it to mellow before I can see how it really feels.

Curious...

Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 4:22 am
by DirtyRAT
I am curious how the tire upgrade on the Stella fared after your initial windy weekend (Just had one in San Diego, as well).

I've considered these http://www.scooterwest.com/items/?_page ... -Walls/466 to keep the aesthetics of my Stella using a better rubber compound. Not fond of the stock tires, either.

Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 2:15 pm
by Redcatjack
Took me less than a month to decide on tossing the Sava POS tires. Put Heidenau K58's on last week and there was an immediate improvement across the board, especially road feel. Well worth the $110 investment.

Re: Curious...

Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 7:03 pm
by desmolicious
DirtyRAT wrote:I am curious how the tire upgrade on the Stella fared after your initial windy weekend (Just had one in San Diego, as well).

I've considered these http://www.scooterwest.com/items/?_page ... -Walls/466 to keep the aesthetics of my Stella using a better rubber compound. Not fond of the stock tires, either.
Much better. Holds a line in a corner instead of feeling all squirelly.

About those Continental whitewalls... apparently they are no longer made in Germany, but in Taiwan (?) and now you are paying the German price for Taiwan quality.

I have heard that if you want white walls, the Maxis ones that come standard on the Buddys are ok.

I do really like the way whitewalls look on this bike. But I much prefer a solid feeling ride.

Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 9:10 pm
by Silver Streak
I had my dealer swap out the Sava whitewalls for Shinko whitewalls before delivering my 4T. Probably not the best, but they feel OK so far.

Re: Curious...

Posted: Thu Apr 21, 2011 3:26 am
by DirtyRAT
desmolicious wrote:
DirtyRAT wrote:I am curious how the tire upgrade on the Stella fared after your initial windy weekend (Just had one in San Diego, as well).

I've considered these http://www.scooterwest.com/items/?_page ... -Walls/466 to keep the aesthetics of my Stella using a better rubber compound. Not fond of the stock tires, either.
Much better. Holds a line in a corner instead of feeling all squirelly.

About those Continental whitewalls... apparently they are no longer made in Germany, but in Taiwan (?) and now you are paying the German price for Taiwan quality.

I have heard that if you want white walls, the Maxis ones that come standard on the Buddys are ok.

I do really like the way whitewalls look on this bike. But I much prefer a solid feeling ride.
Thanks for the reply! after 250 miles on the new Stella, I get it about how the stock tires feel squirrely. Do you have a URL for the whitewall Maxis tires? I'm likely heading to Marina Del Rey to try on some of those Corrazzo jackets soon, so if those tires are local in L.A., I might pick some up...

Re: Curious...

Posted: Thu Apr 21, 2011 3:45 am
by Dooglas
DirtyRAT wrote:[ Do you have a URL for the whitewall Maxis tires? ...
So, have you talked with Scooterwest? They have carried Maxxis in the past and I presume they are one of your local dealers.

www.scooterwest.com

Re: Curious...

Posted: Thu Apr 21, 2011 7:08 pm
by desmolicious
DirtyRAT wrote: Thanks for the reply! after 250 miles on the new Stella, I get it about how the stock tires feel squirrely. Do you have a URL for the whitewall Maxis tires? I'm likely heading to Marina Del Rey to try on some of those Corrazzo jackets soon, so if those tires are local in L.A., I might pick some up...
I can't find one.

But your local scooter shop - Motorsport Scooters - should be able to hook you up. I'd give them a call.

As for the Corazzo jackets, I'd call ahead to see if they have what you want. The MDR shop is really nice, but it may save you some aggro.

Posted: Thu Apr 21, 2011 7:51 pm
by BuddyRaton
Redcatjack wrote: Put Heidenau K58's on last week and there was an immediate improvement across the board, especially road feel. Well worth the $110 investment.
My favorites! Don't forget that tires need to break in!

Posted: Thu Apr 21, 2011 8:55 pm
by ericalm
From what I think I read elsewhere, the Maxxis whitewalls are no longer available in a 3.5 x 10. Don't know if any of the similar sized tires would fit a Stella, but on the 4T you def. can't go any wider due to rear shock.

I really liked the look of the (Michelin S83) blackwalls on my Stella for some reason. Easy to keep clean, too!
Redcatjack wrote:Took me less than a month to decide on tossing the Sava POS tires. Put Heidenau K58's on last week and there was an immediate improvement across the board, especially road feel. Well worth the $110 investment.
Interested to hear impressions of K58s after a while. I know a number of people who hate them for riding in dry, warm weather. Too hard and rough!

Have I mentioned my love for the Heidenau K61s in this thread yet?

Posted: Thu Apr 21, 2011 10:31 pm
by Lovelandstella
ericalm wrote:...I really liked the look of the (Michelin S83) blackwalls on my Stella for some reason. Easy to keep clean, too!...
Aaaaaaand I just remembered I have not been cleaning mine. dirty. shucks.

Posted: Sat Apr 23, 2011 3:55 pm
by Steady Teddy
Any of you guys tried the Zippy 1s on your Stella or P Series scooters?

http://www.scooterwest.com/item_details ... ippy-1/468

I have them on a couple of my scooters, and they stick great, track true and even feel solid on the freeway for short hops.

Can't beat the price, either.

TC

Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2011 4:59 pm
by desmolicious
Steady Teddy wrote:Any of you guys tried the Zippy 1s on your Stella or P Series scooters?

http://www.scooterwest.com/item_details ... ippy-1/468

I have them on a couple of my scooters, and they stick great, track true and even feel solid on the freeway for short hops.

Can't beat the price, either.

TC
The last Zippy 1s I saw are no longer made in Germany, but Taiwan (I think).
I have been told by people who have used them that they may look like the Zippys of old, but do not handle as well as them.

Anyway, this weekend I rode my PX and Stella 4T back to back. Both now have the same tyres - s83 - same pressures and.... the PX is definitely more solid and stable. Nothing at all wrong with the Stella but it just does not feel as together as the PX.
Guess that is the difference between a monocoque frame, and the duocoque.

Doesn't make a difference to how I feel about the Stella, still diggin' it. And that's what matters.