Page 1 of 1

which topcase?

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2012 12:38 am
by kmrcstintn
I am seeking info and feedback for purchasing and installing a quality topcase on my Buddy 125; my previous one (a Scootr Logic) worked loose (after the tab that locks the case to the baseplate bent) and flew off the scooter after hitting a series of crappy road repairs...

I want one that either mounts directly to the rack or has a very, very secure locking/latching mechanism; I also want to get one @ 29 or 30 liters in capacity; thank you

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2012 12:39 am
by Drum Pro
Givi is the best bet...

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2012 2:46 am
by pdxrita
Givi is certainly top quality if money is no object. If, however, you don't want to spend that much, Shad cases are good too. I've got a Shad SH33 that works great. It even survived my recent accident with only a scratch. A lot of people buy the SH29, but I wanted a bit more room than that, so I got the 33.

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2012 3:27 am
by cfargo
Drum Pro wrote:Givi is the best bet...
+1

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2012 3:59 am
by Bluduh
I've also got the Shad 33 and am happy with it. It has a quick release for easy on/off, but *seems* sturdy enough to remain on the scoot and NOT come off unexpectedly. I've hit some pretty good sized pot holes without any problems.

The case actually mounts to a sub-base that is bolted very securely to the rear rack. With the top case off, you can still use the rear rack normally, like when you need to bungee a bulky load onto the rear rack that won't fit in to the top case.

Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2012 10:53 am
by kmrcstintn
thanks...I'll have to narrow down my choice;

for now I have a milk crate attached with heavy duty cable ties (aesthetically deficient, but practical as heck)...I was able to carry home 3 gallon containers of 15w-40 motor oil from NAPA the other day and keep them in there with a cargo net; I just kept the speed down a bit and avoided things to cause excessive suspension travel

Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2012 2:33 pm
by ThreeSheets
GIVI or SHAD are the top two as far as quality top cases go.

Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2012 4:31 pm
by skully93
sounds right!

The genuine cases are....well they're just crap. I use mine and got a great deal on it, but it's still crap :P.

Posted: Sat Jun 09, 2012 7:35 am
by michelle_7728
Another option:

There's this thread on building the platform. This allows you to take the case off when you want, and still have a little bigger area than your rack allows by itself, to put things on...though that's not why I initially did it. :wink:

Posted: Sat Jun 09, 2012 2:51 pm
by pdxrita
kmrcstintn wrote:thanks...I'll have to narrow down my choice;

for now I have a milk crate attached with heavy duty cable ties (aesthetically deficient, but practical as heck)...I was able to carry home 3 gallon containers of 15w-40 motor oil from NAPA the other day and keep them in there with a cargo net; I just kept the speed down a bit and avoided things to cause excessive suspension travel
I wouldn't recommend carrying that kind of load on the back rack, no matter what kind of storage you have. That greatly exceeds it's capacity and also could cause handling issues. When you have something that heavy to carry, you should either put it on the seat behind you, or put it on the floorboard.

Posted: Sat Jun 09, 2012 3:50 pm
by teacherquinn
skully93 wrote:sounds right!

The genuine cases are....well they're just crap. I use mine and got a great deal on it, but it's still crap :P.
Agreed. On a buddy I don't think I'd go over a 30. I have a Givi 30 on my GTS and I wouldn't want a bigger one. They aren't the most attractive things! More practical than beauty. And you wouldn't want too much weight back there anyway.

Posted: Sat Jun 09, 2012 4:45 pm
by michelle_7728
pdxrita wrote:
kmrcstintn wrote:thanks...I'll have to narrow down my choice;

for now I have a milk crate attached with heavy duty cable ties (aesthetically deficient, but practical as heck)...I was able to carry home 3 gallon containers of 15w-40 motor oil from NAPA the other day and keep them in there with a cargo net; I just kept the speed down a bit and avoided things to cause excessive suspension travel
I wouldn't recommend carrying that kind of load on the back rack, no matter what kind of storage you have. That greatly exceeds it's capacity and also could cause handling issues. When you have something that heavy to carry, you should either put it on the seat behind you, or put it on the floorboard.
+1

In non-rainy weather, I do Costco runs all the time on my Buddy...but I use either saddlebags, behind me on the seat or on the floorboard for heavy stuff...I put the bread, strawberries and potatoe chips in the top case. :P